Welcome to alex wennerberg's website

Who's afraid of death?

Pope Leo is highly interested in the intellectual exports of my city. Recently, he tweeted about the twin ideas of transhumanism and posthumanism and, specifically, their attempts to conquer death and achieve immortality in the material world.

For the immortalists, their means towards living forever vary: for some, eternal life can be achieved merely through an extension of the capabilities of standard medical science. Others are willing to entertain some sort of human-machine hybrid in order to enhance their capabilities far beyond the biological limits of a human body. Others even contemplate uploading their consciousness, somehow, to a computer, transcending their human bodies entirely.

What unifies the thinking of the immortalists is a fear and deep aversion towards death. In their worldview, death is the biggest defect of life, and they speak in breathless terms about the possibility of a future world where death, the greatest evil of life, could finally be made a thing of the past. The pope, of course, disagrees, asserting an acceptance that death, illness, suffering, and above all, limits are a natural part of the human condition, not something that must be exceeded.

Unfamiliar to the transhumanists, but deeply familiar to the pope, is the concept of hubris: the notion that there are boundaries to what human ambition should attempt, that to exceed those boundaries is to risk terrible retribution. The posthumanists in particular are so averse to death they are willing to sacrifice even their humanity to avoid it: in other words, it is because humans die, in their view, that we should question even whether the human condition itself is something worth holding on to, and whether some sort of machine-human or even purely digital existence may be preferable.

On Twitter, tracewoodgrains questioned the Pope's motivations, arguing that Christians do not truly, deeply believe in death. In the Catholic worldview, God grants them eternal life, so of course they don't have to fret so much about infinite life extension. In the secular materialist worldview, shared by all the -ists mentioned so far, death is a cold oblivion.

In this view, common among atheists, Christianity (and all religious stories of an afterlife) is a kind of delusion about the nature of death: religious people comfort themselves with fictitious stories of eternal life, whereas the atheists have the supposedly realistic, hard-headed understanding of death as pointless nothingness. And since no one is here to save us, since nothing is redeemed in death, it is our sole responsibility to conquer this infinite evil, and there is no one to punish our hubris.

I question, however, that the notion of the afterlife is what is essential about the pope's point here. Of course, he, and most Christians, do literally believe in heaven, but more important than that is the orientation towards life that this belief inspires: one capable of accepting death and, broadly, the human condition itself. Assumed in the immortalist worldview is that death is not merely tragic, but intolerable.

I would argue that the immortalists have it reversed: it is the Christians (and, broadly, those who share a similar worldview present in most religious traditions) who more accurately understand the nature of life, and the transhumanists who live in a world of comfort and fantasy. The pope recognizes that there are limits to human capabilities, that death, disease and suffering are inevitable aspects of life. The transhumanists delude themselves into thinking that these things can be transcended. In other words, it is them who need not accept death, because they can fantasize that death is a problem to be solved, and thus they wage an endless war against death, the tragedy coming for us all.

In The True and Only Heaven, Christopher Lasch calls a worldview capable of accepting human limits, frailty and death as a "tragic conception of life." He distinguishes what he calls "optimism" and "hope"—optimism is the belief that human ingenuity can conquer all things, that through the application of science and reason, things can only get better and better: with time, all problems can be eventually solved. Hope, on the other hand, is an orientation towards life that maintains its inherent goodness in spite of all of its problems, in spite suffering and death. The transhumanists are optimists, and as such, are hopeless, finding themselves bitterly condemning the human as something to rage against and transcend.

The Christian, or other religious worldview may teach eternal life, but it is mistaken to think that this is wishful thinking. The notion of eternal life can be a reassuring balm, a medicine that allows one to better accept death when one's time comes: it is a source of courage that strengthens us when facing the tragedy that besets us all. It is the transhumanists, in their fantasy of eternal life in this world, in the infinite capabilities of human reason, who live in a realm of fantasy, their notion of eternal life a dangerous altar at the foot of which that they are willing to sacrifice everything, even their own humanity.