Welcome to alex wennerberg's website

I saw Alex O'Connor

Alex O'Connor is a philosophy YouTuber from Oxford. Last night, I saw him speak at a sold out show at San Francisco's Palace of Fine Arts. I am not super familiar with his content, but I've watched a handful of his videos and got a ticket mostly out of curiosity: what would an unstructured evening with a philosophy YouTuber be like? The event wasn't a lecture, and was only sort of a conversation: mostly it was more like an in-real-life version of watching O'Connor's YouTube channel. Leaving the venue, I heard someone remark that they listen to O'Connor's (usually very long) videos in the background while doing something else, and how the in-person venue gave them a space to to give him their undivided attention.

O'Connor mostly focused his talk on a number of well-tread philosophical questions: does God exist? Is morality objective? Is materialism or idealism true? These questions would be covered in any introduction to philosophy course, but in the Anglo-American world, few people, even few college-educated people have had any formal philosophical education at all. The content of his talk was less interesting to me than the form of his project: O'Connor has succeeded in introducing a wide audience not just to a certain set of philosophical beliefs (although he does have his), but, more impressively, to the humble, curious mindset required to begin the project of doing philosophy at all.

As a vice, I occasionally watch Jubilee's "surrounded" series, wherein one person debates twenty-five others in rapid-fire succession. These videos are, almost universally, awful, no matter the topic and who is on each side. Shockingly, O'Connor, the 1 Atheist in 25 Christians vs 1 Atheist, managed to turn this hostile format into something not just bearable, but even at times enlightening. His claims were measured and specific, and the Christians were disarmed by a conversation with an atheist who, at the very least, respected their faith and took seriously their claims.

Early in his talk, O'Connor made a comment about the quality of online discourse: for example, Christians online are so used to hostility that O'Connor merely trying to accurately articulate their worldview led some to believe that he was secretly a Christian: why would an atheist think so deeply about Christian philosophy otherwise? O'Connor is surprised by this: he described himself as simply clearing a "very low bar" of approaching philosophical conversations with curiosity, openness and respect.

Surprisingly, this approach has been rewarded enormously (O'Connor has 2 million YouTube subscribers) on platforms whose algorithmic and cultural pressures generally push creators in the opposite direction: towards combativeness, insincerity, smug condescension. These traits are so common not just in online discourse, but in American public life that O'Connor simply making the baseline effort towards the honest intellectual engagement required to do philosophy makes him quite unusual.

In the Q&A portion of the talk, I was struck by how devoted his fans were: an 18-year-old audience member said that O'Connor inspired him to study philosophy in university. Another, who came in costume (sporting a false mustache to match O'Connor's) said that O'Connor was the most important person in her developing her philosophical worldview. Another echoed this comment, and O'Connor responded responded with self-deprecating humility. O'Connor views himself as clearing a "very low bar" of good faith and respect, but upon reflection, is the bar her clears really that low? I know I certainly have not been able to clear it every time I discuss politics and philosophy, and I especially would struggle to imagine being able to do so in an environment as hostile as social media, or even God forbid a Jubilee "surrounded" series. To clear this "very low bar" may, in fact, take a quite exceptional character.

Also on Substack