How to spend $100 million
On Thursday, Anthropic went public in the second-largest IPO in history, after only SpaceX's earlier this year. If its stock price holds, over 400 employees, mostly in the Bay Area, will be worth over $100 million.
$100 million is a difficult amount of money to spend. You could purchase gauche, pointless super-yachts, or maybe you could buy a sprawling mega-mansion. As much as this may be, for some, a nice fantasy, the reality is far less practical. You would have to leave San Francisco to enjoy this level of consumption, and you would have to develop a new social network around people who find this sort of ostentatious display of wealth acceptable. Certainly, you could purchase a very nice home, but that is how you spend $5 or $10M, not $100M.
Many in the tech industry, it is hard to believe, also don't really think in terms of luxury consumption. Some thought Sam Bankman-Fried's schlubby cheap uniform of a T-Shirt and New Balances was a carefully constructed way to come off as a humble, non-materialistic guy. To some degree, it was, but there are also a lot of people in this industry who really are just like that. Despite the effort of some to create a facsimile of a real class hierarchy in San Francisco, the culture of SF resists this kind of attitude towards wealth. The obsession of some techies with "status" belies the fact ultimately, the city, despite its enormous wealth inequality, lacks the rigid structure of an actual class society, despite some of the tech right's laughable attempts to create one.
In other words, this is California and you can't buy "status," you can't really buy anything beyond a certain point. To me, an archetypical (and even admiral) billionaire is Mitchell Hashimoto, who, after making his wealth, stepped down from his CEO role to become an engineer at his company, before eventually quitting to spend his time, among other things, writing a tech blog and doing coding puzzles. Some want techies to treat their wealth like this is Miami, but, for better or for worse, that just isn't in their nature. A lot of this crowd, famously, doesn't even drink.
Instead of consumption, primarily, the nouveau riche are interested in spending their money charitably. Dario Amodei and other co-founders have dedicated 80% of their equity to philanthropic giving. Even low-level employees, now mere decamillionaires, apparently, are eager to discuss how to give their newfound wealth away. If they aren't, mostly, going to spend it on themselves, what should they spend it on?
New York Magazine lists a number of New York-specific projects that these newly-minted billionaires could contribute to: a music teacher for every middle school, urban gardens, new parks, upgraded NYCHA basketball courts, and so on.
These are generally not the priorities of the newly-wealthy Anthropic folks. Like Sam Bankman-Fried before them, they are often interested instead in a movement known as effective altruism, which seeks to "optimize" donations based on maximal "effectiveness." To this crowd, the New York Magazine list could not be more offensive: it is hard to imagine a less "effective" project than upgrading NYCHA basketball courts. That single grant alone would be nearly seven times greater than the entire annual revenue of, for example, Shrimp Welfare Project. Even if we limit ourselves to comparatively less-effective human charities, according to EA-aligned GiveWell, about $3,000 given to one of their charities saves one life. Applying a ruthlessly utilitarian logic, this would mean the opportunity cost of NYCHA basketball courts is about 6,000 lives. Sure, basketball is nice, but is it worth leaving 6,000 people to die?
On some level, this logic is tempting, and effective altruists generally do not take this to such an extreme, but tolerate a "both-and" approach. The Giving Multiplier encourages you to augment "your favorite" charity with a donation to a highly effective one. Still, the notion that the entire Curbed list consists of NYC-specific civic works projects is totally anathema to the EA worldview, as Calum Best articulates.
This is because the EA vision of "the good" is based on a narrow conception of the purpose of charitable giving, that of private, individual suffering. "Squishy" goods, like, for example, the globally unique character of New York's civic life, are at the very least, overrated in their view. To some more utilitarian-minded EAs, this concept itself is incoherent: the "goodness" of New York City civic life, or any other moral virtue like "honor, "equality," or "dignity" ultimately can be reduced to the positive and negative feelings that it inspires in people in aggregate. The idea that there are good or bad things you can do for a city, or for a public, somehow separate from the good of its individual citizens' capacity to feel good or bad is, to them, incoherent.
This conception of humanity is fundamentally individualist: even in their "selflessness," EAs see individuals not as members of a community, but rather atomized units of private pleasure and suffering. They do not conceive themselves, as, for example, "New Yorkers," or "Americans," members of a political community which has shaped their identity and towards which they have social obligations.
It is only in breaking down this individualist conception of morality that New York Magazine's projects like NYCHA basketball courts become coherent. In the EA worldview, the courts bring NYCHA residents some amount of quantifiable joy: a pretty small amount compared to the suffering of, for example, dying of malaria. In a more civic republican, virtue-focused worldview, the good of the NYCHA courts is how they contribute to New York's civic life: they provide a gathering place and a means towards developing one's excellence in sport. They also make New York greater: a city unique in America in its public life. A lot of NBA players got their start on NYCHA courts, but the idea that "excellence in basketball" could be something "good" and New York's ability to cultivate it might contribute to a sense of civic pride is completely foreign to effective altruists, or at the very least something they would put extremely low on their list of priorities.
In addition, while they may believe in frugality, EAs do not generally believe in social equality—for the EAs, the fact that so many EA-aligned people have so much wealth now is something to celebrate, not lament. Equality, again, is a kind of squishy virtue that doesn't really fit into their worldview: rather, their focus is on suffering, and in their view, an unequal distribution of resources, if well-applied, can actually be more effective at alleviating it than, for example, the messy, but more egalitarian approach of democratic political action.
This is what the New York Magazine article understands: the best thing that those blessed with enormous wealth can do is to, essentially, un-do the damage caused by such enormous concentrated wealth and power. The effective altruists instead want to divert their wealth towards something "better": to in some way, justify its accumulation and concentration, rather than to, properly, renounce it. To renounce one's wealth means making it, to the greatest degree possible, something given not to projects of their personal liking, but the public at large, repairing the damage that such terrible economic inequality has caused. If anything, I would perhaps invert the EA Giving Multiplier: newly-wealthy EAs should, sure, give a small amount of money to their favorite EA-aligned charities, but give the rest of it back to the civic institutions that make the cities and communities that they reside in great.
Also on Substack